All articles
authentic leadership / imposter feeling in leadership

Six signs you are leading from someone else's playbook

Borrowed leadership is hard to see from the inside. These are the signs, and what to do about them.

Nobody decides to lead like somebody else. It happens by absorption.

An early manager who was good at the job. A founder you admired. A book that arrived at the right moment. You take on the style because it works — and it does work, for a while, because it worked for them.

The problem shows up later, when the fit stops being close enough and you cannot work out why the job has become so tiring.

Six signs.

1. You are tired in a way that rest does not fix

There is workload tired, which a holiday resolves. And there is a duller, more constant tired that survives two weeks off and is waiting for you when you get back.

The second kind usually is not about hours. It is the cost of continuous translation — converting what you actually think into what the role seems to require, all day, every day.

2. You have a mental model of "a real leader" that is not you

Notice whether you have a picture. Most people do, and it is often a specific person.

If your internal standard has a face, you are measuring yourself against someone else's operating system. You will always fall short of it, because you are not running that system, and the shortfall will read as personal inadequacy rather than as a category error.

3. Your best decisions happen away from the room

You are clearer on the walk home than in the meeting. You write a good email at eleven at night that you could not have said at two in the afternoon.

That gap is the performance. In the room you are managing how you come across; alone you are just thinking. If the quality difference is large, a lot of your capacity is going into presentation.

4. You dread a specific recurring situation, disproportionately

Not general nerves. One specific format — the board update, the all-hands, the one-to-one with a particular person — that costs you far more than its importance justifies.

That is usually where the borrowed style fits worst. The situation demands the thing you are pretending to be, and the pretending is most expensive there.

5. Praise does not land

When someone compliments your leadership, you feel a small dissonance rather than satisfaction. Somewhere under it is the thought that they are responding to the performance, and that if they saw how you actually operate they would think differently.

This gets labelled imposter syndrome, which I think is often the wrong diagnosis. Imposter syndrome is feeling like a fraud when you are competent. This is something more accurate — you genuinely are presenting something that is not quite you, and part of you knows it.

6. Your development goals have not changed in five years

Same feedback, same intentions, no movement. Be more decisive. Be more visible. Delegate more.

If a goal has survived five years without progress, one of two things is true. Either you do not actually want it, or it is not a real gap — it is a demand that the model makes and your nature does not support. Both are worth knowing. Neither is fixed by trying harder next year.

What to do about it

Do not attempt a personality change. That is the same mistake in a new direction.

Start smaller: pick one recurring situation and do it your way once. If you think slowly, tell the meeting you will answer by Thursday instead of producing something on the spot. If you are direct, be direct instead of wrapping it in three layers of softening.

Two things happen. It costs you less than you expected, and the response is better than you feared. People largely prefer a leader who is consistent and legible over one who is performing a style, even when the style is technically more impressive.

Then do it again somewhere else. That is the whole method. Stop forcing yourself, in one situation at a time, until the way you lead is actually yours.